Nick cheating on Sharon with Phyllis was one of the most emotional and controversial stories in The Young and the Restless history.
After Cassie’s death, Nick and Sharon’s marriage began to fall apart… and Nick found comfort in someone who understood him in a different way. At the same time, Sharon was leaning on Brad Carlton, Phyllis was still tied to Jack Abbott, and one affair started pulling multiple families into the fallout.
What followed changed everything: the Nick and Phyllis affair, the moment Sharon found out, the Sharon vs Phyllis rivalry, Phyllis’ pregnancy, the Los Alamos wedding, and the birth of Summer Newman during the famous ice storm.
In this Y&R Retro Recap, we’re looking back at the affair that divided Y&R fans into Phick vs Shick… a debate that still hasn’t really ended.
If you watched these episodes back in 2005 and 2006, you probably remember exactly how intense this storyline felt. And if you’re newer to Young and the Restless, this is one of those stories that explains a lot about the relationships and rivalries that still shape the show today.
So I’m curious…
Where did you stand back then—and where do you stand now?
Phick… or Shick?
Let me know in the comments.
Get exclusive updates, fun extras, and personal notes — then check out my audiobook, The Fauna and the Flora.