16 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

DIANNA
DIANNA
Board Member
2 years ago

I like Tucker in the turtleneck as it makes him look sophisticated and mysterious. He look like he should be sitting in front of a fireplace with a pipe and a good book while sipping on a glass of wine. I did a quick little google search on the turtleneck and It has been said that the turtleneck has an element of danger to it. Due to it’s design of being tight around the neck, the garment is representative of having a grip on you. This could be said of Tucker and anyone who feels they are victim to him.… Read more »

Sherrita
Sherrita
Senior Executive
2 years ago

I just feel no matter what Billy wears. He’s always sexy and I cannot say the same for Tucker.

Toni
Toni
Senior Executive
2 years ago

I voted Billy. He has that Cary Grant style of acting and appearance, and Cary wore a turtleneck. On Ali’s comment that the “nice turtleneck” quip might have been ad-libbed. I agree. Jason is an excellent actor, but I imagine him keeping more to script. Trevor (in this and previous roles) has a casual flippancy that sometimes seemed ad-libbed. Remember him playing with Dominic?

TB84
TB84
Influencer
2 years ago

Sorry Tucker, nothing against you (you pull the turtleneck pretty good too) but Billy wins! He’s doing it longer than you Tucker and still looks steamy in it ;p 🙂 Go Bill!

GARY
GARY
2 years ago

I felt I was too good to participate in this shallow poll but I’ll tell you who wears it best. I woke up at 4:18 AM and flipped on the TV before planning to turn it back off to continue sleeping. It was on ME TV, retro station I use to watch The Waltons (a REAL family dynasty) and there was Jed Clampett but he wasn’t in Bev. Hills so I figure this must be Barnaby Jones. (never seen it) Who is that very handsome dude in the brilliant periwinkle blue turtleneck sweater that is totally making my screen pop?… Read more »

GARY
GARY
Reply to  GARY
2 years ago

What shade is ‘periwinkle’ exactly?

GARY
GARY
Reply to  GARY
2 years ago

Ali, I was looking at your photos and its actually true. Billy looks good in a turtleneck but Tucker has the perfect sardonic face for it. Oh, yes. I remember the ‘dickie”. I had a real one and a made up one torn from an old shirt for school. Which is best? Turtleneck or dickie? In layering, with the dickie you don’t have the added bulk. Lace up shoes or loafers? At Buster Browns i was informed at an early age that I had flat feet and needed the lace ups over a slip on. But everything is not all… Read more »

sueW
sueW
Heir Apparent
Reply to  GARY
2 years ago

Wow- in reading what was to me a long-forgotten M.F.U. name, I realize Tucker kind of reminds me of illya K! (Idk if that’s good or bad). But ANYWAY Gary, I have no doubt you effortlessly can rock a turtleneck – gold or otherwise – so of course! you are on the Idris and George (and Randy! lol lol) list! Along w/ any and all t-neck/dickie wearing Chatters – guys AND girls. (I already know that collectively we are an elite and fashion-forward bunch to be sure.) But as far as the rest of the male gen. pop. incl. the… Read more »

sueW
sueW
Heir Apparent
2 years ago

I’m generally not a fan of guys wearing turtlenecks (ok, maybe on Idris Elba -StringerBell! – or George Clooney) and I don’t like them on either Billy or Tucker. While Billy looks dang hot! in all black, my vote goes for Tucker, as for some reason imho the turtleneck seems to suit his appealingly smarmy character…

sueW
sueW
Heir Apparent
Reply to  Ali
2 years ago

Ahahahahaha, I must agree!! How could I have forgotten…!?

Ellen
Ellen
Heir Apparent
2 years ago

100% Tucker. He has the swagger to pull it off. And once they put Billy in that red velvet Broadway usher jacket for Victoria’s Tuscany wedding, he’s off any fashion award list—permanently.

tnicole
tnicole
2 years ago

I voted Billy, but lets be honest, Rey Rosales wears a turtleneck the best

Ellen
Ellen
Heir Apparent
Reply to  tnicole
2 years ago

True fact.

TB84
TB84
Influencer
Reply to  tnicole
2 years ago

Yeah true. I miss me some Rey and his turtlenecks …

Sharod
Sharod
Reply to  tnicole
2 years ago

I agree with you about My Rey. His demise was wasteful, when the writers decided against putting Sharon back with Nick.